REI Co-op
REI Co-op Magma 15
No citable owner-review average published for this one, so no stars.
The Magma is the bag most people who compare specs end up buying, and the numbers explain why: 850-fill down, 23.3 ounces of it, an ISO comfort rating of 21 °F and an ISO lower limit of 9 °F, for $399. That is a genuinely six-degrees-warmer comfort figure than the 15 in the name, which is the opposite direction from almost every other bag in this catalogue — REI named the bag closer to its limit than its comfort and then published both, which is the honest way round.
Label against lab
Sold as a 15 °F bag; its ISO 23537 comfort rating is 21 °F, which is 6 °F warmer than the name suggests. Plan around the comfort figure, not the label. Why the gap exists
At that temperature the pairing table wants at least an R 4 pad underneath it.
Specifications
Highlights
Features
- ISO or EN rated
- Hydrophobic down
- RDS down
- Draft collar
- Half-length zipper
- Recycled fabric
- Stash pocket
What it does well
- Publishes both ISO figures, and the comfort rating of 21 °F is only six degrees off the name — the smallest gap in this catalogue.
- 23.3 ounces of 850-fill hydrophobic down for $399 is the most insulation per dollar of any down bag here.
- Half-length zip with a draft tube and a full draft collar, in a 15-denier recycled shell.
- Sold through a co-op with a real returns policy, which matters for a bag whose fit you cannot judge in a photograph.
What it costs you
- 34 ounces is heavier than the premium 20-degree bags, though it is also a colder bag than they are.
- REI does not publish shoulder girth, so the fit has to be judged in a store.
- The size run is not fully tabulated here — only the Regular's figures were verifiable from published sources.
- Retail-channel only, so there is no built-to-order width or overfill option.
Those two lists are drawn from REI Co-op’s published specifications and from reviews that measured them. They are not owner sentiment — anything owners said appears under its own heading below.
What owners say
Distilled from owner discussions and long-term published reviews, not from anything measured here.
The Magma has become the reference point in budget sleeping-bag discussion, and for an unusual reason: it is the bag people use to explain how temperature ratings work. Owners quoting ISO figures at each other reach for it — a 15 that rates to 9 limit and 21 comfort — because it is the well-known bag that publishes both.
The technical praise is specific too. Owners describe the short box baffle construction, sewn about an inch deep with roughly four inches at mid-baffle, and compare it favourably with a respected cottage maker's approach. That is not the kind of detail people usually volunteer about a retailer-brand bag.
Owners say the same thing every time: wait for a sale, and if you are unsure about quilts, buy the quilt in the same line because you can return it.
What owners like
- It is the bag owners point at when someone asks for the best budget option, with the standing advice to buy it on sale.
- Owners cite the ISO figures directly — a 15 that rates to 9 and 21 — and use it as the worked example of how the standard works.
- The construction gets technical praise: short box baffles sewn about an inch deep with a four-inch mid-baffle, a design owners compare favourably to a well-regarded cottage maker's.
- The quilt in the same line gets recommended as a low-risk way to try a quilt, because a shop with a returns policy is behind it.
- Owners report REI-branded gear generally as good quality, with better available only at meaningfully higher cost.
- Owners describe REI-branded gear generally as very good quality, with better available only at meaningfully higher cost — and name this bag as the example.
Common complaints
- Tall owners note it adds real volume to heat, and a long version of a roomy bag is a lot of air for a cold sleeper.
- The best prices depend on sales, which owners treat as the normal way to buy it rather than as a bonus.
- Nothing about it is unusual, which is both why it gets recommended and why owners rarely enthuse.
Questions owners ask
What are the actual temperature ratings?
Is the construction any good for the price?
Should I wait for a sale?
Is the quilt in the same line worth a look?
REI Co-op Magma 15, head to head
Others in the same band
More from REI Co-op →
NEMO
NEMO Riff 15
The Disco's trimmer, more expensive sibling: the same Spoon silhouette and the same Thermo Gills in a narrower cut with 800-fill down instead of 650. That buys four ounces and half a litre of pack space for $100. Whether that is a good trade depends entirely on how far you are carrying it — for a weekend it is not, for a long trail it very much is.
Best for: Side sleepers going long enough that four ounces matters
Full spec sheet
Big Agnes
Big Agnes Torchlight EXP 20
Two zippered expansion panels run from shoulder to footbox and add five inches of girth on each side — ten inches in total — which makes this the only bag here whose fit you can change after you have bought it. Zip them shut on a cold night and it is a normal mummy; open them on a warm one and it is closer to a semi-rectangular bag. That is a genuinely good answer to the problem that a bag tight enough to be warm is too tight to sleep in. The trade is 40 ounces and a manufacturer-only 20-degree rating with no lab figure behind it.
Best for: Sleepers who want a mummy some nights and room on others
Full spec sheet
A sleeping bag with no zipper at all: a sewn tube with a hood, which is the lightest way to build a closed bag and the reason the Standard/Medium comes in at 18.8 ounces for a 20-degree rating. Zpacks publishes target loft (2.5 inches for the 20 °F version) and exact shell and down weights for every one of the twenty-one size combinations, which is more transparency about construction than anyone else in this catalogue offers — and no lab rating at all, which is less transparency about temperature. Getting in and out means going through the top, and the bag cannot be vented on a warm night.
Best for: Thru-hikers who want a hood without a quilt's drafts
Full spec sheet